Archive for June, 2007

Celebrity Cartoonist Behind Hate Website

Murad Gumen, the Turkish-American author of this famous Micky Mouse cartoon is infamous for his part time job – he is the covert webmaster of tallarmeniantale.com, a website that denies the destruction of over a million Christian Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World War I.

Gumen has been using the pseudo name “Holdwater” in denying the Armenian Genocide and comparing Armenians to rodents.  Keeping his real identity secret for many years, Mr. Gumen is now in hot waters.

A Turkish professor of Armenian Genocide, Taner Akcam, is the hunter of Mr. Gumen.  Prof. Akcam, author of recent bestseller on the Armenian Genocide, was repeatedly called “terrorist” in Mr. Gumen’s website leading to a 4-hour detention of the Turkish historian during a recent trip to Canada.

Prof. Akcam, a long time human rights activist now in exile from his native Turkey, apparently did not endure the personal attacks against him.  He did what an average historian would do: go after the documents and sources used on the racist website.

File six in the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum Institutional Archives, Accession no. 1997-014, box 152 was the answer. This was a personal communication that “Holdwater” made reference to not realizing it was public domain. Making reference to “Holdwater’s” xenophobia that he would lose his job if his identity were revealed, Prof. Akcam the “terrorist” used a nuclear bomb called revealing the truth.

And the truth is – “Holdwater” is Murad Gumen, a celebrity Turkish-American cartoonist and creator of “Wonderguy” (1993) with an unbelievably “wonderful” hate for the Armenian people and the tragedy called genocide that they experienced in 1915.

Taner Akcam’s two articles on Holdwater in English are available and originally published at Blogian.

Identity of Holocaust Denier “Holdwater” Busted

Genocide denier Holdwater is in hot waters. Apparently the anti-Armenian idiot behind “Holdwater” is Murad Gümen, a Turk living in the United States.

Taner Akcam, the first Turkish scholar to openly acknowledge the Armenian Genocide, has busted the identity of “Holdwater,” a vicous anti-Armenian and genocide denier whose www.tallarmeniantale.com hatesite is the Idiot’s Guide to Denying the Armenian Genocide. 

Murad Gümen is the idiot behind tallarmeniantale.com and many other genocide denial letters and pseudo-names such as Ilyas Botas and many many others that we don’t know of yet. 

Prof. Akcam told me about this finding on April 15, 2007 and promised me to send the English version as soon as it was published in Turkey’s Agos newspaper.  Please find the English version of Akcam’s articles being published for the first time:

Holdwater: “The Mysterious American Who Drives the Armenians Mad” –

Part 1

Taner Akçam

On 27 July 2005, Yeni Şafak newspaper published an interview, “The Mysterious American Who Drives the Armenians Mad,” about an “interesting and unique” person who writes under the pseudonym Holdwater. “This mysterious American has been financing, for many years, a highly effective, US-based Internet site,” Yeni Şafak reports. “The primary aim of Tall Armenian Tale: Other Side of the Falsified Genocide is to provide substantial responses to the Armenian Diaspora’s claims of genocide.”

According to the newspaper, Holdwater, a New York native, was born in the 1950s to Turkish parents who had migrated to America in the 1940s and raised their son without teaching him a single word of Turkish. He champions the Turkish theses [denial of the Armenian Genocide—ed.] on his Web site at www.tallarmeniantale.com.

Holdwater says he uses a pseudonym because he is the target of threats and sabotage on a daily basis. “If I tell you my real name and you publish it in your newspaper,” he told Yeni Şafak, “trust me, within a few days neither my family harmony nor my good business nor my Internet site would still be in existence.”

While afraid to disclose his own name because his peace will be disturbed, Holdwater does not hold back from publishing the photographs of intellectuals such as Halil Berktay and Müge Göçek [of the Workshop for Armenian-Turkish Scholarship—ed.], and parading them as targets in his articles full of animosity and hatred. It is quite difficult to understand how someone who is afraid of being attacked can organize such ruthless campaigns of belligerence against others.

I too am among Holdwater’s priority targets. He leads the campaign against me, along with institutions such as the Assembly of American Turkish Associations (ATAA) and the Turkish Forum. He publishes articles on his site which claim that I am a terrorist; that I am responsible of the death of Americans in Turkey; and even that I have planned and organized murders of American civilians. He publishes a list of my “terrorist activities” from the years 1974-75, including precise dates and locations. The list he has published is actually ordinary, small scale arrests during student demonstrations of the era, which didn’t even make the press at the time. [See “A Shameful Campaign,” Armenian Reporter, March 17, 2007—ed.]

It doesn’t take too much intelligence to guess who might have passed to Holdwater the police records of these insignificant arrests, whose dates even I had forgotten. But here’s the real problem: Those who funnel this information to Holdwater as “Taner Akçam’s terrorist activities” are actually taking advantage of Holdwater’s ignorance about Turkey.

Poor Holdwater thinks these arrests were for “terrorist activities,” not realizing that they were all related to crimes of leafletting and postering, for which police permission had been obtained. He seems to have no idea that in 1970s Turkey, one had to obtain permission from what is now called the Security General Directorate’s Special Inspection Branch Directorate for the Associations, and that even with a special permit in hand, one could be arbitrarily arrested and apprehended at police headquarters for 3-5 days.

Once I was arrested for an issue regarding the Cyprus landing. As the Student Association, we were distributing authorized leaflets against the [Turkish] military invasion of Cyprus [1974]. Despite showing our permits, we were held for 2-3 days at police headquarters.

The other actions Holdwater has publicized as my ‘terrorist activities’ are related to our demand for the foundation of a student representation office on campus, where we could voice our issues with the university administration. All this is slightly difficult to understand for someone who was raised and educated as an American.

In addition, whoever passed to Holdwater the information about my arrests forgot to send him my photograph. Therefore, for a long time, Holdwater represented me on his site with a photograph of a PKK member.

Those who are carrying out a campaign against me, portraying me as a “terrorist,” are exploiting this “mysterious American” called Holdwater. Their calculation is simple: To make use of the “terrorist” image which took root in the US after September 11. They are expecting favors from a mindset which labels as “terrorist” both a person arrested for handing out flyers in 1974 and those who attacked the Twin Towers in 2001.

With this attitude, they are actually making fun of Americans, too. After all, here we have a “terrorist” who has carried out direct “terrorist activities” against Turkey; and what is logical would be to get hold of this terrorist and hold him to account according to Turkish law. Or at least give information to Americans regarding the past activities of this “terrorist,” his investigation and trial.

Instead, they are telling the Americans something which amounts to: “We treat this man as a citizen with a clean record, but could you be so kind as to treat him as a terrorist?” Because, in fact, the citizen in question had his prison sentence annulled with changes made to the Turkish Criminal Code in 1992 and also has a document stating he has a “clean record.”

Ignorant as Holdwater is about Turkey, it is impossible for him to understand all this. What I find difficult to understand is why this “mysterious” person is so full of hatred and animosity and why he organizes campaigns of belligerence against others despite stating that he is very afraid. I wouldn’t even want to imagine that Holdwater, who describes his appearance as that of “a typical Christian who goes to church with his family on Sundays,” does not know of the Christian teaching which proclaims: Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.

Next week, I want to take a closer look at the Holdwater issue.

Edited from a translation by Nazım Dikbaş for Agos newspaper (May 18, 2007). The July 27, 2005, interview in Yeni Şafak was conducted by Ali Murat Güven.

____________________________

Holdwater: The Golden Rule

Part II

Taner Akçam

In his interview with Yeni Şafak newspaper on July 27, 2005, after stating the reasons for withholding his identity, Holdwater says, “I have been able to sustain this struggle for thirty years because I have been able to keep my mouth shut. So please do not push me too much on this sensitive issue.” Holdwater claims to have exceptional skill at protecting his anonymity.

I don’t know if anonymity lends a special mystery to Holdwater and a special meaning to his work, or if it makes people wonder, “Who, actually, is this person?” It didn’t strike me that way. I had no interest either in his writings or in his Web site—until he took on a key role in the campaign against me.

One of Holdwater’s important arguments in this campaign was that a complaint should be filed with American immigration authorities, denouncing me as a “terrorist.” Now, I don’t know if he actually did such a thing. Nor am I aware of a direct link between his argument and my recent four-hour detention at the Canadian border. But I did mention Holdwater and the campaign in an article I wrote on the detention. [See “A Shameful Campaign,” Armenian Reporter, March 17, 2007—Ed.] Holdwater wrote a 30-page rebuttal, full of lies, insults and attacks.

Holdwater relies on the fact that his name and address are withheld. “No-one knows who I am, so I’ll say whatever I like,” he must think.

This approach of Holdwater must be curbed, and he must be reminded that every game must be played according to its rules. To shamelessly insult others while hiding one’s own identity fits with no proper principle. It’s a disgrace, to say the least.

Holdwater’s claim regarding his intense effort to conceal his identity doesn’t seem to…hold water. Or he doesn’t take historians seriously enough. He doesn’t know we are enthusiastic about documents and love to trace them. To sum up, he has shown a certain degree of carelessness, the kind of carelessness committed by an ordinary person who fancies himself as very clever and more intelligent than others.

Introducing himself on his Web site, TallArmenianTale.com, Holdwater published some correspondence he sent and received in his own name—taking care to omit his name before posting the letters online.

According to this correspondence, Holdwater wrote to President Jimmy Carter on April 2, 1980. This letter was forwarded to the United States Holocaust Memorial Council, an organization established by the United States Congress in October 1980. [The USHMC is the governing body of the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, DC.—Ed.]

On June 2, 1980, Council Director Monroe H. Freedman answered Holdwater’s letter. One senses from the reply that Holdwater’s objections to referencing the Armenian Genocide were taken seriously. Freedman states that he lacks sufficient information on the “Turkish theses” and asks Holdwater to forward citations of relevant sources.

This, of course, is a great honor for Holdwater. Therefore, he sees no harm in publishing a facsimile of Freedman’s letter on his Web site, with Holdwater’s name removed. Also posted at TallArmenianTale.com is another letter he wrote, this one to the New York Times. We understand from this second letter that, on September 5, 1980, Holdwater had responded to Freedman’s June 2 letter.

I don’t know whether Holdwater is aware of this, but the Holocaust Memorial Council and the Holocaust Museum it governs are public institutions, and therefore, this correspondence is available to the public. Which means, in accordance with the principle of transparency, that anyone can view the originals of Holdwater’s letters.

Once you have the text of Freedman’s letter dated June 2, 1980, and published by Holdwater, as well as the information that Holdwater wrote a reply on September 5, 1980, it is rather easy to access these documents. The Holocaust Museum must provide this information to anyone who demands it.

Yes, Mr. Murad Gümen, or, to use the English alphabet, Murad Gumen; as you see, one doesn’t have to be comic-book detective Kerry Drake to find out who you are (Murad Gümen understands very well what I mean). Tracing the documents published by you has proved sufficient. I believe you will stop taking historians so lightly from now on. As you have understood, we are talking about a document that you yourself have also published.

All I am saying is, to prevent any distortion and alteration of the document, that the name on this document, which you effaced, is Murad Gümen. In a sense, I am rectifying the alteration you made on a document presented to the public.

As you may know, we scholars don’t particularly appreciate the alteration of documents. Such distortion is the reserved occupation of the Turkish Historical Society.

Attacking others, and insulting them, while concealing your own name, does not fit moral conduct at all, Mr. Murad Gümen. Believe me, I am still quite curious as to why you think that I, and many others in my position, do not deserve a right you so readily claim for yourself.

Dr. Akçam, a professor of history at the University of Minnesota, is the author of A Shameful Act: The Armenian Genocide and the Question of Turkish Responsibility (2006). The present article has been edited from a translation by Nazım Dikbaş for Agos newspaper (May 25, 2007). The July 27, 2005, interview in Yeni Şafak was conducted by Ali Murat Güven. Holdwater’s presentation of his correspondence with Monroe H. Freedman was accessible at www.tallarmeniantale.com/holocaust-memorial.htm as of May 25, 2007. The correspondence between Murad Gümen and Monroe H. Freedman is in the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum Institutional Archives, Accession no. 1997-014, box 152, file 6.

Another Place of Memory Erased in Azerbaijan

Vandalized graves; broken stones.  Another Christian cemetery has been erased in the Republic of Azerbaijan this time containing not only Armenian, but also Russian, Georgian and Ukrainian graves.

 

Photo: The burial monument of Tamara Akhoomiants, an ethnic Armenian, vandalized

According to photographs and information posted at Dpni.org, a conservative website from Russia, “Recently im Baku – the capital of Azerbaijan – an old Christian cemetery was destroyed. Hundreds of graves of Russians, Armenians, Georgians, and Ukrainians were barbarically demolished by bulldozers. ”

Photo: Dead residents of a Christian cemetery being “evicted” from Azerbaijan (again)

Shockingly enough, the photographs of the now-gone cemetery were taken in December of 2005 – the same month when the medieval Armenian cemetery of Djulfa was reduced to dust by the Azerbaijani army. 

According to the website, the cemetery is being replaced with elite houses. 

Genocide & Apathy: its intertwined journey

My good friend Oreet, who used to edit Blogian several years ago, has set up her own blog at YourHub.com.  Titled the Mind of Oreety, the blog features her first post – “Genocide & Apathy: its intertwined journey.”

“Never again” the Jews proclaimed as they walked out of the ashes of Aushwitz- Birchenau, Buchenwald and all the other camps of terror, death, famine and injustice.

Such a thought, such a proclamation undoubtedly uttered and escaping out of the trembling mouths of countless individuals who have suffered at the hands of evil; the Armenians, Rwandans, and now the victims of Darfur.

The world watches, immobilized and thinking, “Such a calamity, what sorrow, but what can a mere person do under such circumstances?” Thus, one continues to view the atrocities unfolding, to take another breath, as those whom are helpless are taking their last.

The world is not in search of a savior, or a mythological creature that shall render all that is the epitome of injustice in this world nullified, but we are in search of human compassion and words to be not solely founded upon thoughts, but actions.

Crackdown on Internet Media in Azerbaijan

It has been several weeks since the independent Russian-language “Realni Azerbaijan” Internet newspaper from the oil-rich former Soviet repulic has not been updated after Azerbaijani officials closed the website down. I used to read that site often and summarize some of their breaking reportings (such as the recent affair of three Armenian journalists in Nakhichevan).

Just weeks before cracking down perhaps the only independent Azerbaijani voice, a court in Baku sentenced its editor to 2 and a half years in jail for having visited Armenia and questoned the official Azerbaijani line in regards to the 1992 massacre of several hundred Azeri civilians in Khojalu during the Karabakh war between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

The colleague of the jailed editor was killed last year after comparing Azerbaijan’s regime to a Sicilian mafia.

I guess the most troubling aspect about this oppression in Azerbaijan is the world ignorance and Sacha Cohen continues to be the only person to have ridiculed autocrat president Ilham Aliyev whose photo apears at the end of the credits of Borat.

Sneak Peak of Zvartnots’ New Terminal

Its great look makes me want to travel to Armenia this summer (if Kerkorian reads this post perhaps he could help me with an airline ticket :D)

Set to serve passengers in a few hours, a new terminal at Armenia’s Zvartnots International Airport reminds of overrich Saudi Arabian malls (not that I have seen one lol).

Thanks to my good friend Anna in Yerevan, who worked in the last several years on this new terminal project, we have a sneak peak of the beautiful part of the used to be infamous for service Airport.  Lragir also has an article on last Friday’s dedication.

Borat of Karabakh?

The Christian Science Monitor has an article about Artsakh (The Republic of Nagorno Karabakh) with its Prime Minister Anoushavan Danielyan depicted with Armenia’s flag (the actual Artsakh flag is slightly different) in a Borat-fashioned cartoon.

« Previous Page