Armenia: Marshrutka Democratization
My 6-year-old niece brought up a discussion of societal corruption this week while riding with her parents the public minibus – known as “Marshrutka” in Armenia and in other ex-Soviet countries.
She unintentionally prompted a democratization discussion by singing a song for the passengers who enthusiastically clapped at the end. One of the older woman passengers asked my niece, “When will you be performing on stage?”
“It is $1,000 to perform on stage,” answered my niece – suggesting that the answer was “never.”
The passengers got angry at a society where a 6-year-old talented child knows she has little prospects to succeed since the charge for a single performance is $1,000.
Does talent matter? My niece has been attending a world-famous children’s sing group/school in Armenia for a few years. She is one of the two, if not the only, student who has been continuously receiving straight “A”s, and her teachers call her “a child with exceptional talent.” But to participate in a local national festival with a solo performance, group parents need to pay $1,000 for production, dress, etc. And the only qualification for students to participate in the performance is to come up with the $1,000. So talent, in this case, matters not.
To appease the mashrutka passengers, my niece said, “Don’t worry; I am going to leave Arevik anyway.” The passengers got more concerned, “No, please don’t!” The woman, who had sparked the discussion by asking when my niece was going to perform on stage, said, “You will succeed no matter what. Don’t worry.”
Isn’t something wrong in a society where a 6-year-old knows that the price for “success” is $1,000?
6 Responses to “Armenia: Marshrutka Democratization”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
R on 23 Mar 2009 at 5:32 pm #
What is the price for “success” in the US? What is the price in any country?
Hayaser on 24 Mar 2009 at 2:33 am #
as nice of a story that is, but still yet sad. i would never give 1k to some lil girl to perforrm on stage, there are ppl starving/suffering in our Hayrenik and she wants 1k to perform on stage? for what? for who? to entertain? will that bring her millions of dollars so she can give it to starving/suffering ppl in rural and other poor settlements?
i would die for your neice, i would take away her pain
i would die for any of our Haykakan manukner u yerexaner
but here is prime #1 example why i would not give her 1k to perform….performing is a luxury, not a priority necessity
i am very assured she can do with out a 1k dollar performance where as another 6 yr old child cannot due with out bread, drinkable water, and have decent conditions to live & raised in
these videos are why
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J-DryFPd6GI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hd25cU79Eug
i sent 300 dollars to NGO Tufenkyan Foundations Armenian Emergency Relief Fund (AERF) and ill be sending another 500-700 more in summer (hopefully if i dont go more broke than i am now) and if this JEWmerica is willing i can send another 500-1k in end of year to COAF (Children of Armenia Fund)
so lets see who has balls to ask why i dont give this money for Simon’s neice
Blogian on 24 Mar 2009 at 3:38 am #
Hi Hayaser:
First of all, my family doesn’t have $1,000 or even $200 for performance. Second, even if we did, we would never pay money for her to perform on stage. If she is the best student in her age group as her teachers say, then she should be the one performing on stage, not the students whose parents are not ashamed to give $1,000 for “success.”
The point is that the group she goes to is a business trying to rip off from parents. While this is not unique to Armenia, it is still sad that a well-known Armenian singing group is doing nothing more than making money off the children they are supposed to teach.
I totally agree (and so does my niece and her parents) that $1,000 could be used more wisely than for performing on stage. The point, again, is the sadness that a 6-year-old child knows that she cannot perform because her parents are not rich.
Hayaser on 25 Mar 2009 at 4:53 pm #
axper cavt tanem eli, i understand that it is sad for her to know that she cannot perform because her parents dont have money to make it happen, but they need to be worrying about other things than to perform. she is 6, why she is worrying bout performing? why she is not like other 6 yr olds who are worried bout making friends and hoping they will be with their friends next day. our Hayastan is turning for worst, its becoming worse and worse now every year rather than better and better it was nearly 4-5 years ago.
mer Hayerin cavt tanem eli, iranc kyankin mernem, dzer kyankin mernem. mer Hayeric lav@ ch’ka ba mer Hayastanic lav@ ch’ka
Aron D on 30 Mar 2009 at 7:42 am #
Well, the little girl should be allowed to perform free of charge. why not just let her perform. it is the duty of the authority to take care of the cost of the event. let anychild who has a talent share it with the public. case closed.
Bani on 02 Apr 2009 at 8:24 am #
it’s amazing how hayaser is totally missing the point, it’s actually quite* entertaining